Monday, October 24, 2005

Black Friday

I am looking forward to watching 2 Hindi movies, the DVDs of which I have acquired recently. One is the movie called “Yahaan” based on issues in Kashmir, and the other is “Dansh” which is set in the backdrop of the north-eastern rebellion. The common underlying theme of both these movies is the fact that they deal with real issues which are contemporary in a sense. When it comes to Hindi movies, though I can watch any form of it and enjoy it too… be it a senseless comedy or a Hollywood-inspired thriller or a timepass ‘masala’ flick, there is nothing which gives me a bigger kick than off-beat ‘real’ cinema which brings to the fore factual events and their repercussions.

This is the reason why, when I aimlessly wondered ‘which was the best movie that I have seen this year’, only one name came to my mind - Black Friday. I guess many would not even have heard the name of this movie, since it has not yet seen the light of the day. Most people would not even know that this movie is a real-life peek into the plotting of the Mumbai Blasts in 1993 and the police investigations thereafter. It is the only movie which gives a blow-by-blow account of why and how the blasts took place and how the Mumbai police unearthed the entire plot.

All the movie does is portray the bare truth, in its most naked and pure form, not mincing any words, not adding any dramatization, not falling prey to any exaggeration, and not fearing any aftermath. It portrays every character with total honesty and candour, and does not even try to assign aliases to the actual names. So, in the movie Tiger Memon is called Tiger Memon and not “Panther” etc like most Hindi movies are prone to do. And Dawood Ibrahim is called Dawood Ibrahim and not some ‘Javedbhai’ or ‘Malikbhai’ like he would have been called in an average Hindi movie. This is just one of the many reasons which make Black Friday special. And, this precisely, is one of the main reasons for the film not having released yet, in spite of all its honesty and portrayal of truth.

This was supposed to be director Anurag Kashyap’s first movie. However, the talented director, who also wrote Satya and scripted Shool, has been labeled a ‘jinx’ since then, because his previous venture Paanch, also got stuck (with the censors for excessive violence) and subsequently Alvin Kaalicharan got stalled due to Anil Kapoor’s late withdrawal. I am already a huge fan of Kashyap, and hope that his bad days are numbered so that we get to see more of his films soon, including the under production ‘Gulal’

I had first heard about Black Friday when Indian Ocean came to our campus during our cul-fest ‘Unmaad’ and played the brilliant composition ‘Bandein’ from the movie’s soundtrack. The next thing I heard was that the release of the movie had been stayed by the High Court in response to an appeal by 36 under-trials of the case who had feared that the movie could prejudice the outcome of the case, which is underway in the TADA court. In around February, one of my best friends told me that he had seen this movie in a film festival in Pune, and praised it no ends. In Sydney, the movie is freely available at all Indian DVD stores, and it was in May that I had borrowed it from a colleague and watched it.

The movie is based on journalist S. Hussain Zaidi’s book, which accounts for the bomb-blast trials and investigations straight from the police record. The irony of the matter is the fact that the book has long been released uninterrupted and without any issue. However, when it came to the faster and far-reaching medium, the parties and the courts both reacted swiftly and did, what in my opinion, is a suppression of the constitutional right of freedom of speech. A movie narrated out of a book already in market, and which has facts straight out of the police records has no strong reason not to be released… and the reason given here is to supposedly protect the accused and charge-sheeted people who are responsible for causing a tragedy of massive proportions and who are supposed to be terrorists with established linkages to the ISI.

I realize that I belong to the lucky few who have had the privilege of watching this superb and passionate piece of cinema, and anyone who has seen it would agree that the film deserves to be shown to the larger audiences, and the government, instead of putting a restraint order on it should rather be making it tax-free so that the world can know about the plight that thousands of our countrymen were subject to in this incident, and the efficiency of the Mumbai police and the CBI in unearthing the plot. Some of the sequences in the movie are a revelation with respect to the working of the police and their hands-on approach and dedication.

The movie starts predictably in a police custody cell on 9th March 1993, when a bashed up Gul Mohammed spills the beans about the conspiracy to bomb major locations in Mumbai. However, the police make a mockery of his statements only to find their feet in their mouths 3 days later when it turns out to be true. What follows is a minute by minute account of the blasts, the supposed rationale behind them (which was to save the face of Islam in India) and the entire modus operandi which was carried out with near precision with 12 blasts occurring serially. Then follows a detailed version of the police investigation and the breakthroughs made by them.

Kay Kay Menon is quite impressive as Rakesh Maria, the officer who was behind the whole operation, and Aditya Srivastava as Badshah Khan has done a good job as well. These 2 actors are steadily becoming the stalwarts of parallel cinema, like Om Puri and Naseeruddin Shah used to be in the old days. Anyways, here is hoping that Black Friday sees the end of the day, and that Anurag Kashyap gets what he deserves… which is, acclaim and applause from much more than just a handful of film-festival audiences.

Will sign off with the movie’s opening line, a quote by Mahatma Gandhi:
“An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind”

Update : On a different note, a request to all readers to please visit this, and do whatever they can for the Earthquake Victims.

22 comments:

eV said...

> anyone who has seen it would agree that the film deserves to be shown to the larger audiences

I agree, but only because imo it would burst the hype that has been created due to the court proceedings. I found the film to be pretty average-ish and am pretty sure it would've "bombed" :)

I'm looking forward to laying my hands on Dansh DVD - no hope of it being released in a Chennai theatre :(

Zulu said...

Get a copy back from Sydney so that I can see it too!

Yahaan is a pretty good watch - Jimmy Shergill has come of age as an actor.

Nirav said...

@eV: I would disagree. For me, the movie was an eye-opener and I think it was quite well made too. However, I am quite surprised that you have seen it... how did you lay your hands on it?

@Zulu : Will get a copy for you, but the print would be quite bad, and more importantly, there would be no subtitles :p

anthony said...

haven't heard of dansh.. will google it right away.. Please do write up a review on that or mail me..

DD said...

BF (Black Friday :p) is available on pirated DVDs in Bangalore, a copy of which one of my friends caught hold of. I was 'kind' enough to share it with eV. But, I was bored halfway through the movie, mebbe bcoz if was less cinema and more reality; and for this genre you need some drama, which BF seems to lack maybe because most of it seems to be very obvious. Something was missing. Maybe the story was too real.
Also, This is Anurag Kashyap's second movie. Paanch was his first, which also starred Kay Kay and had a bl00dy awesome rock song (Main Khuda), the mp3 of which I m still searching for!

Filtered Sambhar said...

Hey nirav,

I personally thought this was one of the better movies I have seen. The main reason behind that was Indian ocean....they were simply awesome, I must say!

It was nice that u have written on this.

Get sambharred!!!
Filtered by sambhar....

km said...

Very good coverage on a film about such an important phase in Indian history. Hope it finds a wider release in USA/UK etc.

Minor inaccuracy: it is Tiger MEMon, not MENon.

Krishna

Aditya Bidikar said...

I have seen the movie (in a packed auditorium in the PIFF) and I agree with eV here. The movie is average, not that well-made, and lacking in emotion. And if you have seen the much, much superior Amu (which is on a similar subject), Black Friday seems utterly pedestrian. Also, it lacks the sensitivity and abhorance of violence that is present in Amu.

prasoon said...

saw the movie in may n recently i happened to see "the final conclusion" - the movie on gujarat riots n somehow am feelin ashamed to be called an indian [the reason being - i kinda have to realise that all this happened after what we indians did : first get the babri down n then burn the train] - i really don't have to tell who brought the babri down - whatever the case had been and who caused the riots - everyone i guess is aware of the nhrc report n the scientific investigation of the burning train - the riots we know were caused by who n who silenced the police/military from taking action - twas all WE INDIANS..

Minal said...

Hi Nirav,
Have been waiting for this movie, realistic movies are hard to come by!
I was eager to watch Yahaan, but then it disappointed in parts. Jimmy Shergill is good, but the ending again felt a bit hindi-movie like.

Nirav said...

@Anthony : Would definitely write about Dansh if it appeals to me. But, given my current situation, I might take some time to get to watch it.

@DD : I guess the fact that there is no surprise element or dramatization might make it dull for a few people, but the fact that it is an exact portrayal of the happenings made it special for me

@Bharath : The song Bandein is awesome too!

@KM : Yep.. I guess it is Memon... would make the change.. thanks :)

@Aditya : I guess I'll have to watch Amu soon then. Also, as I had remarked earlier, this one needs to be seen as a documentary and not a movie, since there is no dramatization or story-telling involved. But, the fact that all of it is a fact did hit me!

@Prasoon : Very true... these movies do make you introspective, and show you the cruel face of humanity... such a welcome change from the feel-good Karan Johar type flicks

@Minal : Taking a cue from the varied reactions, I would suggest that you keep your expectations low :) However, anyone who enjoys 'real' cinema would definitely not regret watching it.

Anonymous said...

I thought that the film was a pretty amazing piece of work...if nothing else, the honesty and passion of the maker shines thru in every frame. Met Kashyap when he was in Delhi for some work and he has already moved ahead and is planning a new film (Gulal still remains in limbo). This one will be about a terrorist organisation and how ultimately it becomes the very system that it opposed. And yes, Yahaan is a great film, Kashmir is beautifully shot though Dansh falls short of expectations...but I guess any Bollywood director adopting Death and the Maiden can only be a step in the right direction

oz said...

It is indeed a tragedy that people like Anurag Kashyap don't get the deserved recognition nor do their works of creative art see the light of the day. I had blogged about Kashyap after reading the utterly frustrating news that Black Friday had been blocked from being released.

Vinay said...

Agree about Black Friday. BF is hands down the best Hindi film I have seen this year. I would even go on to say that this is a milestone movie for the genre, last one being Satya, which was incidenatlly co-written by Anurag K himself. Here's a guy to look for.

Yahaan was a big disappointment for me. Poor production values, shady performances. Couldn't complete it. Killed the songs for me, which are absolutely beautiful.

Zulu said...

Ah well, Nirav, my Hindi is far better than you know since you have only been on the receiving end of certain comments I have made in Hindi. I wouldn't mind subjecting you to a few more but I'll reserve those choice remarks for when you return to India. :)

And I think you should watch Amu which was a pretty good account of the 1984 riots following Indira Gandhi's assassination. Again, a fairly important piece of India's history dealt with very skilfully by Sonali Bose, though it only touches on the edge of the political involvement. I thought there was scope for a lot more.

What I'd really like to see though, is a movie set during the Emergency. Other than Hazaaron Khwaishen Aisi, which I really liked.

Nirav said...

@Anon : You have actually met Kashyap? What are you? some film journo kya? Anyways, I did not know that Gulal is also in limbo... now, after 4 failed attempts at getting a release, I am sure that he would be labelled a jinx

@Oz : read your article, and agree with it totally. I hope that at least you have been able to see the movie. Can't wait to see Paanch

@Vinay : Satya is actually the reason why I was looking forward to BF, since I knew that the man who had scripted Satya had directed this one... Hope I get some breathing space soon to watch Yahaan :(

Nirav said...

@Zulu : I know all about your Hindi... you do know all the words that matter and which can make a meaningful conversation :p
Anyways, I have heard about Amu and that it starrs Konkona Sen Sharma, who was quite brilliant in Mr & Mrs Iyer. Amu and even Hazaaron Khwayishen are next on the list following Yahaan and Dansh

jive said...

havent see both the flicks ! maybe i will this diwali weekend :)

Kaps said...

off topic comment -
you might need real player to access the hard talk show. other than that i don't foresee any problem

anthony said...

happy diwali

anthony

Nirav said...

@Jive - You should! Even I intend to watch them soon...

@Kaps and Anthony : Thanks!

Anonymous said...

Can someone please somehow get me
the digital downloadable free and uncut version of BLACK FRIDAY. I believe hard-hitting movies should
be taken to as many people as possible and the Internet seems to be the best medium to do it. This won't be piracy it would infact be a service to the society as a whole.